Mentawai Surf Resort vs Surf Camp: Which Should You Choose?
On this page
In the Mentawais, a surf resort usually offers private bungalows, air conditioning, more facilities and fewer guests per boat, at roughly US$200–650+ per person per night. A surf camp is simpler and more social, often fan-cooled with shared boats, from about US$130–250. Both include meals and daily boat trips; the labels overlap, so compare the details.
When you start looking at land-based stays in the Mentawai Islands, you’ll see two words used almost interchangeably: resort and camp. They are not official categories, and some upscale camps cost as much as resorts. But there are real patterns behind the labels, and knowing them helps you ask the right questions. This guide compares the two side by side, explains who each suits, and shows how to judge any property regardless of what it calls itself.
Mentawai Surf Holiday is an independent planning guide. We don’t own resorts or camps; we help travellers compare options and connect with independent operators.
Resort vs camp at a glance
| Feature | Surf resort (typical) | Surf camp (typical) |
|---|---|---|
| Rooms | Private villas or bungalows, usually ensuite | Simple bungalows, homestay rooms, sometimes shared |
| Cooling | Air conditioning in most rooms, though not guaranteed | Fans common; air conditioning at some newer camps |
| Guests per surf boat | Often fewer, with groups split by level | Often around four to eight, varies widely |
| Meals | Full board, more varied menus, dietary requests handled | Three filling meals, often local and communal |
| Facilities | Pool, spa, yoga or a bar at some | Basic common area, hammocks, board racks |
| Atmosphere | Quieter, more private | Social, surf-focused |
| Published 2025–2026 rates | Around US$200–650+ pp/night | Around US$130–250 pp/night |
These are patterns, not rules. Some camps have air-conditioned ensuite rooms and small boat groups; some resorts are simpler than the word suggests. Always check the specific property.
What both have in common
Whether it calls itself a resort or a camp, almost every Mentawai land base runs the same model. You cross from Padang on a set transfer day, stay a fixed 7, 10 or 14 nights, eat all your meals on site, and surf from a boat that takes guests to breaks within range. Most include a local surf guide on the boat. Both usually leave out flights, alcohol, insurance and often the surf levy of IDR 2,000,000 per surfer per 15 days. And both are limited by geography: the waves you surf depend on where the property sits, not on its label.
When a surf resort makes sense
- You are travelling as a couple or with a non-surfing partner who wants comfort and things to do.
- You sleep badly in heat and want reliable air conditioning and power.
- You prefer smaller boat groups and more personal guiding.
- You want extras such as yoga, massage or a pool between sessions.
- Budget is less important than rest and privacy.
Our Mentawai surf resort guide explains how to compare resorts by region and quote.
When a surf camp makes sense
- You are travelling solo or with surf friends and want a social atmosphere.
- Your budget is tight and you’d rather spend on more nights than nicer rooms.
- You care mainly about waves and are happy with simple rooms.
- You want a longer stay; lower nightly rates make 14 nights more affordable.
Our Mentawai surf camp guide covers what to expect at the simpler end.
The real difference: the boat
The most important factor is often the same at both: how good the surf boat set-up is. A camp with a fast boat, a small group and a guide who knows the area can give you more and better surfing than a resort with an overloaded boat. When you compare any two properties, ask the same questions:
- How many boats run each day, and how many surfers share each one?
- How many boat runs a day are included, and is fuel capped?
- Which breaks are within normal range, and which need a long mission?
- How are surfers grouped, by level or by room?
- What happens on flat or blown-out days?
Cost compared over a 10-night stay
| Item | Surf camp | Surf resort |
|---|---|---|
| 10-night package (indicative) | About US$1,300–2,500 | About US$2,000–6,500 |
| Padang transfer if not included | A few hundred US dollars return | Often included at upper tiers |
| Surf levy | IDR 2,000,000 | IDR 2,000,000 |
| Tax and service | Sometimes included | Sometimes added on top |
Figures are planning ranges based on published 2025–2026 rates and vary by operator, season and occupancy. For a full trip budget, see our Mentawai surf resort prices guide.
Hidden differences to ask about
- Power: some camps run generators only at certain hours, which affects fans and air conditioning at night.
- Water: ask about hot water and drinking water.
- Internet: connections are often slow; don’t plan to work remotely without checking.
- Medical support: ask what first aid is on site and the evacuation plan for serious injuries.
- Non-surfer options: resorts more often offer activities and a lower non-surfer rate.
Can you mix the two?
Yes, and some surfers do. A common pattern on a two-week trip is to spend the first part at a camp close to a cluster of breaks, surfing hard and keeping costs down, then move to a more comfortable resort for the last few nights to rest before the journey home. The catch is logistics: changing properties usually means an extra boat transfer and fitting two sets of check-in days together, which can cost a surf day. It works best when both places are in the same area, such as two properties around Playgrounds, so the move is a short boat ride rather than a trip back through a ferry port. If you plan to split a stay, ask both operators to coordinate the transfer.
Quick facts
- Labels: “resort” and “camp” are not official categories
- Both: full board, daily surf boats, guiding, fixed 7–14-night stays
- Resorts: around US$200–650+ pp/night (2025–2026, indicative)
- Camps: around US$130–250 pp/night (2025–2026, indicative)
- Surf levy: IDR 2,000,000 per surfer per 15 days, either option
- Key comparison point: guests per boat and fuel policy
Frequently asked questions
Is a surf camp worse than a surf resort for surfing?
Not necessarily. The surfing depends on location and boat set-up. A well-run camp can deliver as many good waves as a resort.
Do surf camps in the Mentawais have air conditioning?
Some do, especially newer or pricier camps, but many use fans. Ask before you book.
Are meals included at Mentawai surf camps?
Yes, almost always. Three meals a day are standard because there are few other places to eat.
Which is better for a couple?
Usually a resort, especially if one partner doesn’t surf. Resorts tend to offer more privacy and activities.
Which is better for a solo surfer?
A camp is often better value and more social, and many offer shared rooms to keep costs down.
Compare resorts and camps
Send us your dates, level and budget and we’ll help you weigh resorts against camps for your Mentawai surf holidays. Message us on WhatsApp or email bd@juaraholding.com.
